Issues‎ > ‎Vol6No4‎ > ‎

sjes-10115




The impact of architectural conservation policies on the continuance of heritage buildings - Study of conservation in Sulaymaniyah governorate

1Banaz N Muhealddin , 2Asst. Prof. Dr. Alan Faraydoon Ali

1University of Sulaimani, College of Engineering, Architecture Department  2Sulaimani Polytechnic University


Received: 06/05/2019 , Accepted: 04/08/2019 , Published: 22/12/2019

Abstract:

The issue of conservation of heritage occupies an advanced place in the context of issues of general concern to the nations of the world because it is a clear indicator of the progress of civilizations, from which subsequent generations derive their culture and their architectural identity. This paper is important in terms of philosophical, cultural, economic, and educational and sustainability aspects.
The main problem in the research is the deterioration of the architectural character of the Kurdish heritage in Sulaymaniyah, especially in recent decades. The objective of the research is to evaluate and find the best solutions to the policy of preserving valuable heritage buildings and improving their ability to preserve the architectural identity of the city.
The research focuses on the study of the efficiency of the architectural conservation of the old heritage buildings that underwent the process of conservation and rehabilitation, the failure of the architectural conservation and neglect policies by the authorities has resulted in the removal of the architectural values and the loss of the architectural identity of the city, which led to deterioration and distortion of the architectural character of the Kurdish heritage. The research takes an analytical approach and historical survey to contribute the prevention, deformation, and degradation of heritage buildings. The selected heritage buildings are examples of the restored architectural heritage in Sulaymaniyah Governorate. The research was based on analysis of old documents, photographs, detailed indicators of heritage buildings and surveying of buildings with surrounding areas, as well as the creation of a table to evaluate the conservation policy and analyze the impact of preserving the architectural characteristics of these buildings. The research concludes with a set of recommendations that can help improve the efficiency of architectural conservation and preserve the original heritage elements of the Kurdish community and increase community awareness regarding the importance of preserving this valuable heritage that left from ancestors to remain etched in generations’ memories. The research was able to reach to the results through the analysis of the main and secondary indicators, which are considered as tools of evaluating the conservation process in Sulaymaniyah or anywhere in the world, for protecting the architectural identity and its original characteristic.


KEYWORDS:    

conservation, architectural identity, documentation, deterioration, restoration, rehabilitation

REFERENCES

1-    H. Elborombaly, Integrated Methodology for Redevelopment Heritage cities threw Sustainability, Heritage cities, Luxor, Cairo, Egypt, pp. 12 -17, 2006.
2-    F. Bernard, Conservation of Historic Buildings, third edition, Architectural Press, Linacre House, Jordan Hill, Oxford OX2 8DP, 200 Wheeler Road, Burlington, 2003.
3-    K. Salih, “The effect of architectural for transformation in housing type- Kurdistan houses in Sulaymaniyah a case study,”  M.S. thesis, Sulaimaniya University, Department of Architecture, pp. 84-86, 2014.
4-    N. Hasan, “The impact of urban legislation on architectural identity- an analytical study of Commercial buildings in the City of Sulaymaniyah for the period 2000-2015,” M.S. thesis, Sulaimaniya University,
       Department of architecture,  pp. 62-64, 2015.
5-    H. Mahmoud, “Managing and Controlling the Nominations of World Cultural Heritage Lists,” Ph.D. thesis, Cairo University, Department of architecture, Egypt, pp. 122-125, 2011
6-    S. Al-Qaisi, “Urban Conservation as a Mechanism of Communication between Form and Moral values,” Ph.D. thesis, Baghdad University, Department of Architecture, pp. 89-90, 2011
7-    Sh. Abbas, “The Policies of Preservation of archaeological- Historical and Heritage buildings,” M.S. thesis, Baghdad University, department of architecture, pp.76-77, 2014
8-    N. Rahi, “Heritage in International, Arab and Iraq law,” University of Kufa, Faculty of archeology, M.S. thesis, pp. 111-113, 2014
9-    N. Kareem, “Documents of the architectural conservation of the Baghdad city,” M.S. thesis, University of Baghdad, pp. 6-7, 2005.
10-  A. Taib, “Architectural Characteristics of minarets in Mosul’s old mosques,” AlRafidaein journal of engineering researches, Mosul University, Vol. 1, pp. 3-5, 1999.
11-  R. Garland, “Authenticity and the Post-Conflict Reconstruction of Historic Sites”, CRM: The Journal of Heritage Steward Ship Home, Volume 1-8, 2008.
12-  C. Giuseppe, “Preservation and development: Some Lessons to be Followed, Some Mistakes to be avoided,” one of the researches presented in the Mayoralty of Bagdad 1st International Conference titled: 
      “Preservation and Rehabilitation of Iraqi City centers,” pp. 34-37, 2010.
13-  H. Moatama, “Revitalization of old buildings in Palestine,” M.S. thesis, National Najah University, Palestine, pp. 56, 2007
14-  A. Orbasli, Tourists in historic town urban conservation and heritage management, London and New York, First published 2000 by E & FN Spon11 New Fetter Lane, London EC4P 4EE, 2011.
15-  W. Christoph, and A. janne, Experience with the Rehabilitation of the old town of ALEPPO, BTU Cottbus, a panel presented in the conference of “Urban Development of Baghdad and further cities in Iraq”
       held in Cottbus, Cottbus, Germany,2010.
16-  N. Foster, and Partner 2001. Norman Foster and the British Museum. New York: 66- 82.
17-  K. Green, and R. Heisenbottle, “Final Designs Unveiled for the Miami Marine Stadium Historic Restoration,” February 8, 2018[On-Line], Available: https://www.marinestadium.org/.
      [Accessed: February 21, 2019].
18- K. Green, and Heisenbottle, R. 2018. Final Designs Unveiled for the Miami Marine Stadium Historic Restoration. February 8, 2018 [On-Line]. Available: https://www.marinestadium.org/.
     [Accessed: February 21, 2019].
19- M. Mohammed,  M. Naseeb, and P. Nano, “Urban dimension in the Architectural Product concepts between Local Architecture and global Architectural Works in Some Arab countries,” Journal of
      Engineering Sciences in Damascus University, Vol. 30 - Issue I, 2014.
20-  H. Tai, “Sustainable Preservation of Historical buildings,” M.S. thesis, University Technology, Department of architecture, urban Design, pp. 70-72, 2015.
21-  S. Thomas, “Aleppo Diverse – open city,” one of the researches presented in the Mayoralty of Bagdad1st International Conference titled:“Preservation and Rehabilitation of Iraqi City Centers,” pp. 3-4, 2010
22-  M. Morris, the Economic Impact of Historic Resource Preservation, Executive Officer California Cultural and Historical Endowment, November 2012.                                                                          
23-  C. Giuseppe, “Preservation and development: Some Lessons to be Followed, Some Mistakes to be avoided,” one of the researches presented in the Mayoralty of Bagdad 1st International Conference titled:
     “Preservation and Rehabilitation of Iraqi City centers,” pp. 34-37, 2010.
24- A. Etzioni, Reconstruction: An Agenda, Journal of Intervention and State Building, Volume 1, March 2007.
25- Ch. Adams, “In classification of religions: Ethnographic-linguistic,” Sept. 10, 2018. [On-Line], Available:   https://www.britannica.com/science/ethnography.   [Accessed: Jan.  18, 2019]
26- A. Muhamad, History of Sulaimaniya, Iraqi printing  press, Baghdad, pp. 100- 212, 1951.
27- A. Ismail, “Urban growth in Sulaimaniya city,” Study in Urban Sociology, M.S. thesis, University of  Sulaimaniya, pp. 30-40, 2006.
28- M. Abu El Mahasen, “Landmarks of the Ancient Near East”, Dar Al Nahdah Al Arabiya, Beirut, Lebanon, 2010.